Gas Fires vs. Electric Fires: Which One Is Right for You?

When it comes to home heating, gas and electric fires are two of the most popular options. Both offer warmth, style, and efficiency, but which one is the best fit for your home? As a manufacturer of both gas and electric fires, we at Legend Fires understand the strengths of each type. In this guide, we’ll compare them to help you make an informed decision.

1. Heat Output & Efficiency

• Gas Fires: Gas fires produce a powerful and consistent heat output, making them ideal for larger spaces. Many modern models are highly efficient, converting a large portion of the gas into usable heat.

• Electric Fires: Electric fires provide a steady level of warmth, perfect for supplementary heating. While they typically don’t match gas fires in terms of heat output, they offer 100% efficiency—meaning all the electricity used is converted into heat.

Winner: Gas fires provide more powerful heating, while electric fires offer 100% efficiency with no energy loss.

2. Installation & Running Costs

• Gas Fires: Installing a gas fire requires a gas connection and proper ventilation, which can increase the upfront cost. However, gas is often more affordable than electricity, making these fires cheaper to run over time.

• Electric Fires: Electric fires are incredibly easy to install—just plug them in, and they’re ready to go. They don’t require a flue or chimney, making them ideal for homes without a gas supply. Running costs depend on electricity prices, which can be higher than gas.

Winner: Electric fires are easier and cheaper to install, while gas fires are more cost-effective in the long run.

3. Aesthetics & Realism

• Gas Fires: One of the biggest advantages of gas fires is their incredibly realistic flame effect. Many modern designs mimic the look of a real wood-burning fire, adding a cozy ambiance to any room.

• Electric Fires: Thanks to advancements in LED technology, electric fires now offer stunningly realistic flame effects. While they don’t produce real flames, some models come close to replicating the look of a traditional fire.

Winner: Gas fires provide the most authentic flame effect, but modern electric fires offer impressive realism.

4. Maintenance & Servicing

• Gas Fires: Regular servicing is essential to keep gas fires running safely and efficiently. An annual check by a Gas Safe registered engineer is recommended to inspect for leaks, ventilation issues, and carbon monoxide risks.

• Electric Fires: Electric fires require little to no maintenance. There are no gas connections or ventilation systems to worry about—just occasional dusting and LED bulb replacements.

Winner: Electric fires require less maintenance than gas fires.

5. Environmental Impact

• Gas Fires: While modern gas fires are much more efficient than older models, they still produce carbon emissions. However, newer designs have significantly reduced their environmental footprint.

• Electric Fires: Electric fires can be a more eco-friendly option, especially when powered by renewable energy sources. Since they don’t burn fuel, they produce no direct emissions.

Winner: Electric fires are the greener choice if powered by renewable electricity.

Final Verdict: Which Fire Is Best for You?

At Legend Fires, we offer both gas and electric fires, so we understand that the right choice depends on your needs.

• Choose a Gas Fire If:

  • You want powerful heating for larger spaces
  • You prefer a highly realistic flame effect
  • You’re looking for a cost-effective long-term heating solution

• Choose an Electric Fire If:

  • You need an easy-to-install, hassle-free option
  • You prefer a low-maintenance heating solution
  • You want an eco-friendly alternative with zero direct emissions

No matter which option suits you best, Legend Fires has a range of high-quality gas and electric fires to match your style and heating needs. Explore our collection or get in touch at 01254 695244 or info@legend-fires.com for expert advice.